Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes by Chris Cutcher
Young Adult Realistic Fiction
ISBN: 0-688-11552-7
Suitable for 15+
Readers Annotation: Outcast Eric beats the odds to stay fat in order to stay friends with Sarah Byrnes and uncover her deep secrets.
Plot Summary: Sarah Byrnes is now a mute for reasons best friend Eric Calhoune must find out. They both go way back. They became friends because they were both outcasts; Eric being extremely fat and Sarah for having hideous scars that covered her face and hands due to boiling spaghetti falling on her. Eric looks up to Sarah; she is smart, courageous, and tough. It gets to the point where Eric needs to continue to be an outcast to stay friends for Sarah Byrnes, thus eating more and staying fat even though he joined the swim team, which is making him lose weight. Eric and Sarah have always been picked on and they form an underground school newspaper, Crispy Pork Rinds, which focused on dimwitted bully Dale Thornton. Now Eric must ironically find help in the unlikely source of Dale to find out what has caused the deep repression and silence in Sarah Byrnes, not to mention her terrible secret, which is a challenge that puts Eric in over his head.
Critical Evaluation: This book is very deep with a lot of substance. It isn't linear with flashbacks without warning. It deals with every teen issue from sex to abortion to physical abuse. And these issues involve a number of characters that are all carefully developed. There's a complete back story to note as well, not to mention ironic and very witty. The reader might have to re-read a few sections of the book to get it all in. But it is rewarding and a very original concept. It combines so many genres that for a few pages, the book feels like a comedy, then a sad drama. Then there's Sarah Byrnes. Just the name itself is all you need to know; she even wants to be referred to by this. Her personality has to make up for so much due to her back story that every reader gets teary eyed. And Eric, who is intelligent, is blinded by love, not physical, but emotional, to help his best friend that he literally puts his life on the line. Its these themes of trust and friendship that show that if you believe in something, you can stand up to it and try and fix it.
Author: Chris Crutcher was raised in Cascade, Idaho. He has a B.A. in sociology/psychology and a teaching created credential from Eastern Washington State College. He has written a numerous amount of novels such as Running Loose and Athletic Shorts, both of which were named ALA Best Book for Young Adults. Many of his books are among the most frequently challenged due to the characters dealing with serious teen problems: abuse, religious prejudice, and disabilities, just to name a few.
Apart from writing novels, Crutcher spend five years as director of an alternate school for children from kindergarten age through high school in Oakland. He is currently living in Spokane as a child and family therapis for the Spokane community Mental Health Center. In his spare time, he runs and plays basketball.
Booktalking Ideas:
1) Physical abuse
2) Mental and physical disabilities
3) Violence
4) Abortion
5) Troubled homelife
6) School life
7) Suicide
Challenge Issues:
Due to the detailed depictions of physical abuse, mental and physical disabilities, violence, and mentions of abortion, sex, and suicide, Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes has been one of the most challenged books of recent times.
A librarian should state that the ALA mission is "to enhance learning and ensure access to information for all," which is embodied in the Library Bill of Rights, the Association's basic policy on free access to libraries and library materials. Librarians must act as an extension, making sure that they educate the general public, and themselves, about the nature and importance of intellectual freedom in libraries.
Why Included: I have too many things, some good, some bad, about this book that I had to pick it up and read it. It was a tough concept and I had to re-read some pages but I felt that it was definitely worth it.


